Newk's Eatery - U.S. Hwy N #L Greenwood

We’ve been to this place several times and loved it in the past, but yesterday was a disaster, very disappointing and we fill like we were ripped off! They were out of practicality everything! They served my half of chicken salad on the smallest sliced half of regular toasted bread instead of the bun it was supposed to come on, as well as my husband’s cheesesteak sandwich on the same bread with one thin and rubbery pieces of steak that he did not like. My husband was obviously not full off that tiny piece of nothing, so I went up to get him a chicken salad sandwich and spend another $10+ in addition ti the almost $30 we spent to have an actual meal, but guess what…. They couldn’t make it because they was completely out of bread then…..The potato soup was awful as well, so we couldn’t even fill up on that to compensate due the tiny sandwich that tgey gave us….This was very disappointing and we want our money back! We will never return again! All the other customers were upset and complaining as well! We should’ve known not to stay and eat when there was literally a few people in there and that place is normally jammed packed! They needed to close their doors instead of ripping people off!!!!!!

The last three times we've gone there they have been out of chicken. Two times salmon and beef. The most recent was chicken, salmon, stuff for salads, and no pizza boxes. We loved the Greenwood, Indiana location since they opened. Though quality control has always been an issue. They really lost me when they quit making their own pizza crust. The premade stuff just isn't as good. We continued to occasionally go because my husband was ok with the new crust. But when they don't have any ingredients, they can't even make what you want. We simply quit going.

Really feel as if there’s a failure with management. Used to really love eating here and the atmosphere it provided. However, since recent management changes I’ve just not been able to enjoy myself. Would not recommend until problem is resolved.

I visited one of these in Mississippi and loved the chili so much that I did a Google search and was very excited to find a Newk's Eatery in Greenwood!This time around, I went with a friend who got the half sandwich lunch pairing of the chicken bacon club -sans tomato- and the Mac n Cheese.They really enjoyed their lunch. A lot.Lol.We already know that I love their chili, but, yes, it did not disappoint! I got it loaded as that was how I received it in Mississippi and wanted the same experience.Although Indiana is way more generous with the jalapeños and I actually had to take a cpl out.. yeppers, I was a total wiener biscuit, lol!I look forward to returning and trying a few more things.

The food is definitely not as good as McAllister's. They have good soup.