Paisano's Pizzeria - Randolph

This Pizza had a lot of potential..Very Good Sauce, Very Good Cheese with the crust at Ok. Ordered a Well done Margarita Pie, but could have used more time in the oven to get a little more crisp. This is first visit to this Pizzeria and I was happy with the first order. Speaking of which, you should think about that box promotion to 10 Pizzas Purchases versus 15 that you offer now. I would have to spend $300 before I get a Free Pizza basically. Anyway, I will be back, the place is new, clean and is on the right track with the Pizza. Did not recommend a signature Pizza on the Phone, just started rattling off the menu. I just went with my favorite and hoped for the best.

Ordered via slice, picked up a large extra cheese/half pepperoni, a caesar salad, a greek salad and some garlic knots. The pizza was great, good flavor and the crust was basically perfect. The caesar salad was ok, the greek salad was better and the knots were really, really good. The guys working there were really nice too. Will definitely be back.

Love this place. I just moved to Lake Hopatcong and I order the Spinach Roll through the DoorDash App all the time. The regular pizza and Grandma pies are also very good. I will be placing a large order this coming Saturday 9/17 for another house party. Can't wait!!

Saturday 5 pm. Slice selection very slim. Plan slices looked a day old. Very cheap on the cheese 2 slices and bottle of water $10. specialty slices)

Been here twice. The slices are huge, the prices are fair, and the man behind the counter remembered us and had a friendly conversation with us. This is what I look for when I go out. 6 out of 5 stars. It's obvious they care about their customers and the service and food represent that!!!