Elkton Goodfellas Pizzeria - Feedback

Great place to eat with an equally great staff. Good selection at fair prices. Definitely will be coming back again for more.

Terrific service!! Good food, pleasant surroundings. It's a welcome spot in a quant little tiwn.

Delicious food! Great service and for the money.. the meat stromboli was big and filling.

While passing through I saw the name goodfellas and pizza by the slice thought maybe this was a hidden gem of good pizza,but I was horribly wrong. The sauce the...

Straight up American diner, had what we wanted, prices were right on reasonable.

I got the turkey Reuben on rye with fries. Very delicious with smoked turkey and swiss with sauerkraut and thousand Island dressing with fries. Very tasty. Food...

Pizza a little soggy in the middle but good. Hamburger and onion rings good. I'll be back! Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4...

Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Tomato Sauce Cheese Pizza

Friendly staff, fast service, great local restaurant to try out. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Chicken cheesesteak is Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Love this little place! We were on the way back from Luray and saw Goodfellas. We had to stop and check it. The food was great, expensive good and fast. Our wai...

Loved the Stromboli! However, frozen meatballs and less than.. very disappointed. Even the sauce tasted like Ragu. Anyway, great place compared to others.

I LOVE Goodfellas because they have really good calzones. And I really like there Pizza Rolls. They are also fast with there food and I have been there multiple...

With a small diner feel, the food was tasty yet somewhat generic Italian fare. The steak and cheese special was decent, the spaghetti was okay... but the calzon...

A decent place to get pizza, subs, sandwiches or pasta without breaking the bank. Inside is not unusual, service was hometown friendly and fast. Expect 20 30 mi...

Great place to eat with an equally large staff. Good selection at fair prices. In any case, will come back.

A great pizza place. So cheesy! We ate a veggie stromboli and a calzone. Big portions. It is like vintage and everything is clean and tidy. Our server was very...

This is the first time that I have ever eaten in this restaurant, but I say it has very good tasty food and a very good customer service and affordable prices t...

I never had a bad meal here. Appropriate prices and food is always hot and tasty. I enjoy her steak and cheese and her pizzas.

Great food and incredibly friendly staff. Portion sizes make the prices extremely fair if not a bit abundantly affordable. Only negative aspect was that it seem...