Elkton Goodfellas Pizzeria

Love this little place! We were on the way back from Luray and saw Goodfellas. We had to stop and check it. The food was great, expensive good and fast. Our waitress made us feel at home and we will definitely be back when we go through.

Loved the Stromboli! However, frozen meatballs and less than.. very disappointed. Even the sauce tasted like Ragu. Anyway, great place compared to others.

I LOVE Goodfellas because they have really good calzones. And I really like there Pizza Rolls. They are also fast with there food and I have been there multiple times. :

With a small diner feel, the food was tasty yet somewhat generic Italian fare. The steak and cheese special was decent, the spaghetti was okay... but the calzones are worth mentioning. The large calzone was huge... and this is coming from a Texan, where everything is bigger back home. Good flavors and humongous portion, could have fed the whole table. All in all, nice homey little place with decent eats.

A decent place to get pizza, subs, sandwiches or pasta without breaking the bank. Inside is not unusual, service was hometown friendly and fast. Expect 20 30 minutes during lunch. The owner has two of six tables in the restaurant closed to keep in the customers at a safe distance. Fork and knives are stored individually in a disposable bag. We have ordered three slices of pizza, meatballs parmigiana and steak cheese special. Pizzas were very good, definitely worth five stars, but both subs were nothing special. I have mic feelings about this place, you have to try to be the judge.