Westtown Pizza Corp

Disappointing Pizza was very soggy, sauce was on the sweet side. Food: 1 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Solid pizza place, no major complaints. Had nice staff member when I was there and the pizza was a solid 7.5/10, so good. Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4

Sal the new owner is amazing and the Large pie I ordered was out of this world Service: Take out Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

This place has the worst customer service ever I called and ordered food for delivery here I am waiting over an hour after they said we will see you in an half hour call back get placed on hold and forgotten about now they have the phone off the hook for about 10 mins Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Service: 1

As of the Summer of 2023 there are new owners and with that, their own new pizza recipe. I have tried three different pizza pies from them and decided to write a review with constructive criticism. The new owner and his family own and operate all of the businesses at our neighborhood local. They all seem to be very friendly and nice. With that being said, I have to remind them of a few simple things. Pizza in New York is expected to meet basic standards whether it's in Orange County (full of NYC transplants) or Brooklyn NY. Crust, sauce and cheese. If they are not correct it isn't good. This pizza has no taste. There is no sauce and the recipe is centered on the crust being very soft and doughy like a hot pretzel. It tasted like it was a frozen pizza. It is seriously lacking in what pizza should be and what Westtown Pizza was for all of us here for so many years. I hope that they heed this review and perhaps work on obtaining the original recipe for the pizza that kept people coming for a few decades. There's a reason why the small pizza place in the small, little-known town survived for so long: because the product kept us coming. Please recalibrate your approach on Italian food. It is lacking in flavor and texture. I also want to see you guys succeed.