Nayeli's Pizza - Walworth

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Italian Beef

Everything is delicious! They are always friendly, eating is always fresh. I love this place.

I was very disappointed with my beef stroganoff. It has very little shave beef and was very salty in a thin broth. Stroganoff is usually thicker

We actually wanted to go to a different restaurant in town at first because of a past bad experience at Nayeli’s. Unfortunately the other place was closed. The only other restaurant nearby was not great either so we decided on Nayeli’s. We should have ordered the pizza to go but the kids wanted to eat inside. Bad mistake. The place was filthy. Tables, benches, floors. We were told to seat ourselves. There were 2 tables left very messy after people left so we walked down to some that seemed picked up. Unfortunately they too were disgusting. I wiped the table down with some napkins. We ordered soft drinks but I ordered water. It did not just taste like city water but chemicals. Bad. The soft drinks tasted that way too. We ordered loaded nachos as an appetizer and a large pizza. The nachos took a while. They weren’t too bad but very little ingredients accept lettuce and the chips were fried and dripping with grease. When we started eating a beeping noise started. Like an alarm clock sound. It went on forever so my son followed the noise. There was an alarm clock in the men’s bathroom. Weird. It was still beeping when we left. The place should not have been so nasty and the food should not have taken so long. There were no other people in the restaurant but us and there were 4 people standing around talking in the kitchen. When the pizza finally came, I had it. I asked the girl to box the pizza to go. Instead of bringing the hot, messy pizza to the kitchen to box it for us, she brought the box to the table. There was barely any room and like I said, the pizza and pan were hot. It was difficult to put in the box where it sat on the stand. At least the employees were nice. When we got the pizza home, it was good but lots of burnt chunks on the bottom from what I suspect is a dirty oven. Needless to say, this place is not worth our business. I do not recommend.

My cousin and I got burgers for lunch from this restaurant and they were so good we got burgers for lunch again the next day. A lot of restaurants skimp on the beef or overcook burgers until they're really dry, but these were cooked really well, juicy and flavorful. I would recommend it.