Tony Maronni's - Sussex

Amazing pizza. Got the Hawaiian, Chicken Bacon Ranch and a Cheese. All were delicious. The hand tossed could use a little crispier bottom but that's all. Easily will eat here again.

I've been getting their pizza delivered or carry out for many years. It is the best pizza in Sussex like they say or anywhere. I always get the Sussex Supreme thin crust with no green peppers. I don't understand all the negative reviews. Parking: Plenty of free parking

Horrible service. We used to be all about their pizza and they were the best place in town we ordered pizza from, but we started noticing the service at the restaurant going downhill REAL fast over the past 6 months, especially.The reviews on here noting the loud background noise, unprofessional employees, and forgotten deliveries are right on point.First, let me start by saying we only live 1/2 mile away from the restaurant. This last time we ordered we got 2 medium pizzas and were told that it would be 45 minutes to 1 hour til our order would be delivered. We waited an 1.5 HOURS, still no pizza!! We called the restaurant and asked where our pizzas were. The woman who answered the phone asked, Didn 't you already receive them? After telling her no, we had not, she went to check on them and admitted they were NOT EVEN MADE YET!!! She said that we should have them shortly. She then told us that she only charged 1 of our pizzas to my fiance 's credit card and asked him to provide the information AGAIN. We then waited another HALF HOUR before they even delivered our pizzas. Needless to say, they got no tip and we will never be ordering from them again.Either the owners need to take classes on how to run a business or they won 't have one.

We Only get it DeliveredSo don't know aboutAtmosphere . But We Love Their Pizza We won't even order fromAnyone ELSE . GODBLESS THEM ? ? ?O An A Military DiscountReally Means So Much to Us . As An Disabled Veteran every penny Counts ? ? ?

We ordered the garlic bread which was extremely salty and just seemed to ooze in your mouth. Maybe fried or too much butter? Also ordered the pepperoni calzone which tasted bland. Ordered the meatball grinder hot with Swiss. It tasted very bland, the bread didn’t seem to be toasted enough so the marinara soaked the bread and made it soggy. It had a weird aftertaste and stopped eating it halfway through. The mozzarella sticks we ordered were actually good and I recommend those. They weren’t made with a wonton wrapper which was a breathe of fresh air. Wisconsin, wonton wrappers don’t do mozzarella sticks justice. The fries that came with my grinder were good. A lot of improvement is needed if you are going to stay in business.