Totally Baked On Sanibel

This weekend we discovered Totally Baked in Sanibel. We stopped to taste their donuts and found this little hidden gem has so much more. They have cakes, cake cookies, fresh baked breads and hot carved meat sandwiches served on freshly baked in house bread. We tried a carved piece of turkey and it was very delicious. If we didn't have lunch plans, we would have had lunch here. The staff was friendly, helpful and informative. You also let us sample some cookies that were excellent. The donuts are the raised donuts and they are thick, fluffy and fresh. Great flavors too. Our only criticism is that they package the donuts in the box on their sides so that the toppings on the other donuts and the box. We would have preferred them if they were flat in one layer. We will definitely add this café to our visits when we visit Sanibel Island next.

Amazing donuts and fantastic staff! This place is a jewel in a sea of “mom and pop” specialties restaurants on Sanibel Island. Very recommended, their glazed and chocolate coconuts!!

Put your hands down the BEST glasses donut I've ever had! Melt in the mouth well. But they sell quickly.

Proven breakfast sandwiches and donuts. Everyone liked their choices. I can't wait to try the sandwiches from the big roasts.

Totally baked, totally good! Crab salad on a croissant with chips. Everything is handmade to perfection. This is my go-to place for food and sweets. Yum!