Grinnell's - Rochester

As it turns out, we were here for the very last time since during our meal our server announced that the restaurant would be closing permanently the next day ... and it did! It's really a shame, such a wonderful Rochester tradition closing after all these years!

I’m only writing a review because I think all these 5 star reviews must be fake.We had the New York strip… zero seasoning. Tasted just like meat. Not even a little salt. Had a little brown sauce under it on the plate.Prime rib was huge. But almost completely raw. We ordered medium.Mashed potatoes… again no seasoning. Texture was good. But no flavor.Asparagus had no seasoning, just steam.Then we had the “special” turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes and a tablespoon of cranberry sauce. This was good. But the presentation was odd. Was all in a pile, layered I suppose.The place smelled like sewage or a dry drain when arrived. But it had just opened so I figured maybe they had a dry drain. And based on the reviews we were excited to try it. Unfortunately we won’t go back.I think it’s great so many people enjoy it. But this was just awful. And we had a guest from out of town with us.

Great rating but atmosphere and food didn't live up to the rating....staff was friendly and efficient.... facility is very dark and not inviting.

I took my client here while I was in town. I have to say that this was some of the best service but I've had in a very long time. Everybody was amazingly courteous and right there for everything we needed without us even having to ask. If you like scallops, these were some of the most lottery delicious scallops I've ever had my life. Do yourself a favor and give these folks a visit.

Food was excellent. Service was great from beginning to end. Will definitely go again!