Cape Cod Cafe Incorporated - Raynham

Four of us went the other night to dine in. Ordered four pizzas and drinks. 40 minutes after, I went to the counter to ask if they know how much longer. They had our food wrapped to go sitting on top of the oven. We were eating there! Saw those pizzassitting there for 15 minutes. Had no idea they were ours or I would have asked for them. We were the only ones there, so it'snot like they were distracted. It wasn't busy at all. The EXACT same thing happened to us in 2017. It's why we stopped orderingthere. Then here we are 5 years later and the same thing happens lol. Pizza was ok, but extremely greasey. Had to use a lot ofnapkins to soak the grease up.

Pepperoni pizza was awesome. They are on the smaller side so if you are s big eater don't share one but 2 of us split one for lunch and it was perfect!

Great pizza as always, but I noticed when the employee is busy, can't seem to order right.

This restaurant isn't the worst I've ever tasted, but the glowing reviews seem misleading. The pizzas are extremely overpriced, and while the crust isn't exactly soggy, they tend to overdo it with the toppings, which ruins the dish. If you're in the Raynham area, I'd recommend trying Smitty's instead; it’s just five minutes away and offers great pub-style pizzas (the 10-inch size is similar to Cape Cod's, but somehow feels larger). The buffalo chicken pizza, for instance, has a consistency that's almost soupy—it's hard to describe the texture of the toppings otherwise. It feels like this place may have once been good but lost quality control with its rapid expansion. The flavors are overwhelmingly reminiscent of cheap frozen pizzas, and while the crust is chewy, it remains too soft. Overall, it's really disappointing.

I ordered two partially baked pizzas to take on a drive to Florida, intending to surprise my friend who lives there with them.