Feil's Supper Club - Randolph

Went to Feil’s for Mother’s Day buffet. A one hour drive. A friend recommended it. We were so disappointed. Every entree on buffet was so salty. The bacon dressing on salad bar wasn’t warm, the apple sauce cake dessert was hard. Food wasn’t displayed very nicely. The table clothes were vinyl which is ok for clean up, but they were stained and frayed. Even the old fashions seemed watered down. We were rushed out of our table after 45 minutes. We had reservations and there were many tables open. One thing positive our waitress was excellent. The owners/hostesses seem to be kind the the elderly towns people, we felt since unwelcome and rushed. Never going back. I’ll be sure to post this review on many sites. Disappointed! Worst restaurant I’ve been to in years.

Place was amazing, great food, service, and drinks. My wife and I went on a Wednesday night and we pretty much had the place to ourselves; I was disappointed by this because I have no idea why more people wouldn’t be at such a good place even in the middle of the week. I’ve seen way worse places way more busy, if people want nice places around they need to go to them and support them! Oh and the salad bar was the best I’ve seen!

We wanted to go try a new place to eat. Thought we would drive out and give it a try. We were very disappointed. Our first clue was a pretty empty parking lot. Walked in, pretty quiet. Went to see how long of a wait. Only one gentleman in front of us. He and the hostess chit chatted for 5 or so minutes while we stood there. We got our turn and she said we could be seated or have a drink as the dining room wasn't full. We sat at the bar for a drink. My friend ordered Titos (which he ended up with Grey goose) and I ordered a Malibu (which they also did not have and offered something similar I had never heard of and I've bartended) My friend paid $14 for 2 single short drinks. We went there originally for prime rib. Well they had the German buffet. It looked good. So we decided on that. We were disappointed. The food was mediocre. It was warm at best and my piece of pork was still pink in the middle. The kielbasa in the sauerkraut was even mediocre!! The salad bar was ok. Some good things on there. The bread that was brought to our table wasnt great either. It was pretty chewy. I would have to say the best part of the meal was the Reuben chowder. Not really sure if we will come back and try the prime rib as that may be mediocre as well. Not a good experience.

The bar and the salad bar are great!! Our service was very caring and fast.

Had an amazing experience dining this evening. The aesthetic of the building was very warm and welcoming, and the food and service were phenomenal. Had the South African Rock Lobster, German Potato Salad, and all you can eat salad bar. Would highly