Eilenberger's Bakery - Feedback

Online buyers beware. I placed an order with Eilenberger 's Bakery through Goldbelly on a Sunday. I tried to change my order as I had accidentally placed the wr...

Bought a few cookies. I really liked the praline cookie. All the others were dry or tasted weird (snickerdoodle) and my daughter didn't finish the m&m cookie

This fruit cake was very dry, crumbly, and had no flavor. It was loaded with super sweet, syrupy fruit that overpowered the taste of just sugar. No brandy flavo...

Bakery storefront was nice. I drove 3 hours to purchase a Mary of Puddin' Hill Apricot fruit cake, which are the best! They were out. The lady running the regis...

Just bought a beautiful apple pie from this place!! Our senior class trip stopped by here and they enjoyed stopping in for yummy cookies, fudge and candy.

Just bought a beautiful apple cake from this place! Our senior class travel stopped here and they enjoyed stopping in for delicious cookies, fudge and candy.

Beautiful bakery with a long history in Palestine. Bakery were great, lunch sandwiches were nothing special.

I was shocked how historical it looked when I arrived. The cookies were pretty good! I like the apricot cookies!!!! The prices were decent. The red velvetfoot t...

Great desserts. You have cakes, cheesecakes, brownies, biscuits and candy. The caramel turtle pecan cheesecake is amazing. They are also considered the oldest b...