Celestino's New York Pizza - Oroville

I don't usually do reviews, but I just had to tonight. My husband and I ordered a pizza for delivery not knowing what we were getting, as this was our first time ordering. OMG, the pizza was phenomenal! I couldn't have asked for a better mixture of handmade crust and toppings. The amount of sauce and cheese was perfect. Everything was perfect! Thank you

If you are looking for a pizza slice the size of your face? Craving cheesy stringy goodness from every pull? True New York Flavor Style Delicious Mozzerella Moons that taste like deep fried cheese heaven? Omg, this place is seriously obsessive!!! I crave pizza like I've never craved pizza before, lol. They throw down here, and you can tell they do it from the heart. Everything always tastes fresh, and I've tried almost every pizza they have. I can get full off of 1 slice here! The Joe Pesci is a family favorite, love the Italian garlic, and the Hawaiin style pizzas. Need to try their pastas next, but their apps and pizzas never let us down. Try the Mozzerella Moons we ate them so fast we forgot to snap a pic of the epic pull! Service is always friendly and awesome. We are Celestino Fanatics!

They’re the bees knees! Shout out to no lemon slices you know who you are. Best garlic knots in town, and wait until you try the pizza.

Order one calzone and one slice of cheese pizza, waited over an hour in a hot building cause there was no AC. My husband finally walks up there telling them we want a refund cause it’s been well over an hour and we haven’t received our food. They then started trying to cover their butts saying we put it to go and called out our order when I stated that was a lie cause we even were given eat in cups and the girl who placed our order asked if we wanted the slice of pizza now or if we wanted to wait and have it brought out to our table all together, we’ve been sitting at our table the whole time and not only did they not call out a name or order number they then proceeded to tell us our order was placed under Chris instead of Trisha.. Just lost our business! Left without food and 2 cranky, hungry, over heated babies! Better get our full refund too or there will be serious issues.. We were the only ones left in there and had no food on our table you would think that’d be a red flag or raise concern for them to question maybe just maybe they are still waiting on their food.

I want to leave a great review for the most part ! The food is yum, I love the spaghetti and my girls will often indulge in pizza slices; we visit Celestino’s maybe 1-2 a month. The guys who work at this location are all super swell, pleasant and very customer service oriented. However,, tonight was a horrible customer service experience with an employee named Eva. She was rude, when asked for some napkins and a fork, since there were none in the bag. We were going to order some more garlic knots, but after her annoyance was apparent, I decided not to spend my on anything else. I called to ask for her name, She was very confrontational On the phone and asked , why I need to know information. I stated, because you were rude. She’s started raising her voice and said, “rude how”?! I asked to speak to the manager and I could hear her yelling to him that “someone is saying she was being rude, audible scoff” She is not enjoying her job and it is apparent ! My daughter could come work there and she’s a teenager, she knows how to be nice to people, especially if that is literally one’s job. I don’t always enjoy working, if I’m tired, or stressed out, but you better believe I wouldn’t take it out on my Co workers, or clients. My advice, leave the attitude before you walk through those front doors! I know it’s not a big deal, but I will not be returning and it’s unfortunate, bc the last encounter was awesome with a young gentleman.