Cherry Grove Pizza

Nice outdoor seating area. DELICIOUS gluten free pizza!! One of the best I’ve had.

Best pizza anywhere on fire island! Wish they took cards though.

BEST pizza on fire island hands down. It’s worth it to go to cherry grove for this pizza over the pizza in the pines. I love the triple chocolate mousse cake too — v decadent. The grandma sicilian pizza with added onions, spinach, and pepperoni is YUMMYYYY.

They sell by the slice if you don't want a whole pizza. It was very good and was thin crust pizza.

Have been here a number of times with friends. On the one occasion I go by myself I sat at a table waiting for ANY waiter to pay enough attention to me to provide me with a menu. What is ridiculous is to see how as other people came to sit they provided menus in moments. I sat for 20 minutes patiently waiting and what is even more disappointing and upsetting is that as I stood up from the table I sat at and another party of 4 came to sit at the VERY table I waited to be acknowledged and served.. … – show