The Incredible Pizza Co - Newark

We ordered two Italian subs and one meatball sub. We got three Italian subs and all of them were drenched in dressing and soggy. Pizza didn't have enough sauce and was dry. Delivery time was great for a Friday night and the staff was superfriendly. Overall we won't be ordering from here again

Only place open after 9:00 pm in the Newark area. All other restaurants think it's still Covid Shut Down and does not think anyone needs to eat after 9pm. Great staff of workers, pretty good food, as I have tried most of the menu. Great Potato Skins

Thank you for the amazing subs! This is the only place I can find such delicious sandwiches. Much appreciated!

This is the restaurant I’ve been searching for, so look no further! While other places may close early, these wonderful people cater to those with odd hours who crave pizza after 10 PM in Newark. If you buy 2 subs, you get the 3rd one free, and they are absolutely delicious! Plus, there’s a buy one get one free deal on pizzas of the same size for just $4 more! Make sure to check the menu as prices may vary, but I’m completely hooked on this amazing pizza spot, and I know you will be too! And don’t forget to tip your delivery driver!

There’s a reason why the offer is buy one pizza and get another for $4. However, the subs are quite good, particularly the Italian and Philly cheesesteak.