Bavellie's Pizzeria - Newark

Visit Newark frequently. Ordered a pizza, garlic bread and a sub to a business. Guess I should have learned my lesson in December when I called the manager about his delivery people actually calling when they arrived. I was promised they would call. At one point, they had a young lady who called when she was in the parking lot. Not sure what happened to her, but the guy will just leave it. Everytime. And his manager has an excuse for him Everytime. This was another large order he left to sit cold for anyone to pick up from the front desk. They claim my phone didn 't work the same phone I used to complain. Even if someone 's phone doesn 't work you have a customers email. You can let the business know you have arrived. After speaking with the front desk staff, of course, he just left it! Biting into what I knew would be the last piece of Bellvellies, knowing it would be the last piece to devour, there was a straight, long blonde strand not just on the pizza but COOKED INTO THE CHEESE. Not on top, cooked into the pie! Disgusting. I won 't bother with the current, immature management. Hair in your food is hair in your food unsanitary and disgusting. Tossed the rest of the $50 meal out. If you 're seeking a good pizza place in Newark, Delfelice Bros calls you when they arrive, are of comparable price and absolutely delicious! No negative customer service and no hair. Loved this place once when they were slightly better managed. Only returned because the food was good. Won 't be returning now. And like any ill managed place, they don 't care about loss. Spend the extra couple bucks and get a place that has great food, communicates and is sans hair.

Great food but delivery service is terrible!!!!! We stay at Cherry Valley Hotel which is awesome, and order Bevellies at every stay . Don't order delivery, the one guy always leaves your food at the front desk and doesn't call you. Pizza was cold when we got it. Who ever delivered last night should be FIRED!!!

Had 2 subs. They make their subs with the same pieces used on making pizza. The sausage sub was bits and not a sausage. The Italian sub was all pieces. Overall, I'm not impressed.

Don't believe their delivery times, its WAY faster than you think. food is excellent. have not dined inside so I cannot comment on atmosphere but if its anything like delivery you wont be disappointed. A

First time eating from here. Enjoyed the food i ordered was good price and a plus is that I can get my fav soda there. Plan on ordering from again.