San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina - New York

The pizza i got was extremly salty and fell apart right when i picked up a slice. The crust was so thin that it could have been non-exsitent, and even after adding marinara sauce to it to try and cut back on how salty it was, it did nothing. It was still as salty as before and completly made the taste of the marinara sauce dissapear. Also one of the cheese was metled so much that it could have been a drink while the other cheese did not seem to melt at all and was in clumps on the so called pizza and ended up weighing it down and soggy and not enjoyable to eat at all. Over all 0 out of 10 would NOT recommed for pizza.

Ordered the burger and a pizza. The food didn't taste fresh and the flavouring was off.

Excellent pie and salad. These people are serious and you won't go wrong here.

Delicious pizza, my only go-to for pizza as a born and raised Italian!

Review of San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina I recently had the pleasure of dining at San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina, and it was an experience that truly captured the authentic essence of Italian pizza and cuisine. This charming eatery is a delightful spot for anyone in search of genuine Neapolitan flavors in the heart of the city. Authentic Italian Ambiance: The ambiance at San Matteo is cozy and authentically Italian, with a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes you feel like you’re dining in a small trattoria in Naples. The decor is simple yet charming, adding to the overall rustic and homely feel of the place. Delicious and Authentic Cuisine: The menu is a delightful journey through Italian culinary traditions. Their pizzas are the star of the show, cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven, with a deliciously charred and fluffy crust, and topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Beyond pizza, their pastas, appetizers, and desserts are equally impressive, showcasing the richness of Italian cuisine. Curated Selection of Italian Wines: To accompany the meal, San Matteo offers a well-curated selection of Italian wines. Each wine is carefully chosen to complement the flavors of the dishes, enhancing the dining experience. ‍ Passionate and Attentive Service: The service at San Matteo is commendable. The staff are passionate about Italian food and are more than happy to make recommendations or share insights about the dishes. Their attentiveness and hospitality add a personal touch to the dining experience. Perfect for Families and Casual Dining: San Matteo is ideal for family meals or casual dining with friends. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly, making it a great choice for a laid-back evening out. Convenient Location: Situated in a vibrant part of the city, the restaurant is easily accessible and adds to the charm of dining out. Its location is perfect for both locals and visitors looking to enjoy authentic Italian pizza and cuisine. Overall Experience: In conclusion, San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina is a gem for anyone seeking authentic Italian pizza and dishes in New York City. The combination of their delicious food, cozy ambiance, and excellent service makes it a must-visit spot for lovers of Italian cuisine.