Old Island Pub - New Shoreham

Was there yesterday during the BI Stroll. Only 2 bars open, so they were busy. Seated at the bar we enjoyed 2 drinks each from Alicja, the bartender. I then made eye contact with her twice, but she was busy and didn 't come back either time. 3rd time she walked by I said I know your busy, but 2 waters when you have a chance please. Alicja put up her finger and shooshed me! That made it time for us to go. She found a second to come over as we got up, but we left. I make a few trips to BI each Summer. Old Island Pub won 't be a stop again. Plenty of other options. I understand being busy, but you don 't shoosh a customer like you would a child.

I hit this place up on Taco Tuesday and wasn't disappointed. Great food and beer.

Beautiful pub. Great people. Blue collar type spot. Nothing fancy, which is what I wanted!

What a treat! We were there on Saturday and some locals brought in fresh oyster a buck a shuck. Add a nice glass of wine and enjoy. You must have the local crab soup. It was out of this world delicious!

Friendly service. We had a private function and I felt so welcomed by all there. The food prepared was top notch! Food cooked so uniquely and served to perfection. Will definitely be back! Thank you to all.