Prospero’s Pizza - New Castle

The pizza at this restaurant is good, without any frills. The staff is friendly and the prices are fair. I've noticed that the amount of toppings on the pizzas can vary depending on who makes them. The older gentleman seems to have a better balance of toppings, while the younger guy tends to overload them. Nevertheless, the pizzas are always tasty.

I decided to visit this restaurant based on its positive ratings, but unfortunately, I was extremely disappointed with the food quality. The pizza lacked flavor, the boneless wings were unappetizing and tasted like low-quality chicken, and the cannolis seemed old and had a rancid taste. I expected better given the price point of the menu.

Hot chicken should not be placed in a Caesar salad. It should be cooled to a safe temperature to prevent the salad from becoming unsafe. Serving the salad with hot chicken puts it in the danger zone (40°-140°) for food safety.

Pizza is phenomenal along with the wraps, fries and kids tenders. Food is always hot when it arrives and all wraps, sandwiches, kids meals, etc come with fries.

Would not recommend ordering here. Wait time is horrible food was cold. Ordered online, moved time back 15 mins and was still 20 mins passed moved time. Atleast my dog would eat it but not for human consumption.