The Paper Mill Restaurant, Bar Events

As always eat good. I can't say the same for our waitress. we were 3 people. 1 ordered a soda, 1 ordered a glass wine and the other ordered a chic cocktail. we talked and she always came back for our food order. After the waitress said she didn't want us to think she was neglected. we ordered it. I got our food and never saw her again until we were ready to go. we all had a drink and dessert. we're still going back, we're just asking for another server.

This place was pretty good. the drinks were good, that was in order. the garlauchbrot looked like it was just a ShopRite roll in the half cut with hardly any garlic on it. I have fish and chips that were in order, I should probably have gotten something else, so this is my fault, but my man liked his meal of meerrotem thunfisch. we got desserts too, but I found the key limette cake to have too much salt in the crust and my lava cake came with celestial sauce that appeared on what I didn't prefer if I knew it but the menu didn't say. the personal was very nice and attentive.

Impressed with the quality of food and friendliness of staff. The menu is extensive, portions generous, and when you see locals, you know the place has to be good. Seems the mashed potatoes are from actual taters and not powdered, a good sign.

Really liked this place at first. Ever since new management took over I’ve been very disappointed. I went to the Easter buffet they offered and it was honestly the most horrible food ever. I might give it one more chance in a few months but only because there’s no many restaurants around.Update: absolutely shocked at the reply from the paper mill. I am definitely NOT former management LOL. You would think you guys would try to at least save face and be professional instead of accusing an unhappy customer (formerly a repeat customer, I might add . Continue to provide subpar food and lose customers. You are destroying your customer base!!!! Your food at the Easter buffet was indeed terrible. My whole table did not enjoy it and when the manager(? came and asked us how it was, we said it was good because we were just being polite. We should have told the truth but whatever, it’s too late now. If you move on with the idea that zero people have had bad experiences here, then good luck with that!!!

NICE PLACE GREAT FOOD! Glad we went there Mother's Day even though out of 2 fish dishes at by 330 pm. Entrees come with bread, no side salad.Huge pasta dishes! Tasty Steak! The tables r just spaced right not too close,nice. Also good for big parties. The bar is on other side of hall NOT near dinning room which is good. I WOULD GO BACK!!!!