Bennett Shellfish - MONTAUK

Quaint little place with fresh wild oysters and seafood…. Absolutely yummy… gracious host too! XOXO

Great mom and pop seafood spot with tons of fresh, local, catch options. Found this place on yelp when we were looking for some fresh oysters and they did not disappoint. The fishery is located in the back of the owner/bay man's house and they feature only the freshest long island seafood, ranging from mussels, scallops, oysters, and there famous lobster pie. They also have some delicious chocolate mouse cake, and seafood fixings. The women running the spot was very friendly and helpful. She was also proud to talk about how her husband was a 14th generation bayman and catches what they sell. Definitely recommend if your looking for some fresh seafood to go. They are cash only and have parking in their driveway.

AMAZING seafood and very friendly people! We had few pounds of Fluke and Bass caught the same morning, cooked by the hosts of Bennett shellfish. Absolutely stunning. Then we came back the next day and had lobster, caught the same morning and cooked by the lovely hosts, best lobster I ever ate. We will def come back when we will be around. I absolutely recommend!

Outstanding, delicious lobster rolls! The owners are very nice!! The husband catches all the fish. It's a take out place.

If you want the best shellfish on the South Fork this is the place to find it. Fish is always catch of the day fresh.