Caradaro Club - Milwaukee

Good Pizza not the best though Lisa's or Ann's are the best

My review may be a bit nostalgic, as I remember the Caradaro Club as a bar on Erie Street from my childhood. Back then, my father worked near the Caradaro Club, and he would bring home pizza or take me there to enjoy it. Unfortunately, we moved away from Milwaukee in the mid-1960s. Much later, in the late 1980s, I was stationed with the Army Reserve in the 757 area, close to the old Allis Chalmers site. Once again, I had the chance to indulge in Caradaro Pizza, and it was just as delicious as I remembered from my youth. Now, I rarely visit Milwaukee, but to me, their pizza remains sacred—yesterday, today, and always.

The only truly authentic pizza in West Allis. The crust, the sauce, and the flavors are unbeatable. Enjoy stone-fired pizza that transports you to Italy, right on 70th Street.

I absolutely love their pizza! The crust is incredibly thin and crispy. It may look like a little hole-in-the-wall spot, but the food is amazing! They only offer takeout or delivery options.

I absolutely love the pizza here! It's always excellent. I ordered my pizza at 9:00 and was done by 9:15. I have no complaints!