Colandrea's Pizza King - Middletown

Me and my wife went to Colandrias Pizza today, I had already ordered a half a tray of meatballs to go( which only cost $35 and came with garlic bread and three small loaves of bread).We split a slice of grandma pizza for an appetizer which was out of this world and a seafood combo with Fra Diablo sauce over linguine(with garlic bread and a side salad included) for $21.99 that was to die for. Both of us didn’t finish it,I highly recommend Colandrias Pizza

I friggin LOVE their pizza!!! I left the area 40 years ago but every time I come home to visit family the first thing I do is order a Colandrea veggie pizza. This time I did half veggie half chicken parm… it was to die for. The crust is chewy and the sauce is flavorful. I live in the south and we can’t get pizza like THIS down there. And it was ready in 15 minutes! Best pizza in the area!!!!

I was in town for business and I ordered there wings. There Mild Wing Sauce is the BEST that I have ever had. I just wish I didn't live 5 hrs away.

The rumors are not true! We were hesitant to eat here after hearing they sold and the pizza possibly taste different. It's not true. I grew up on Colandrea's pizza. It is by far my favorite. I am overjoyed that the pizza taste exactly as we remember. It delicious as always. Give the new owners a chance. They will not disappoint.

This was my first time ordering anything after moving to the area. This pizza was the bomb. Crust was a really nice consistency and the toppings….. someone put some love in those toppings. They didn’t skimp at all and I am telling you this pizza looked stunning. Found my new pizza joint : Looked so good I forgot to take a picture of it before ripping into it.