Caputo's Pizza - Middletown

Caputo is great. the food tastes authentic and the service is care. I visited the restaurant of new windsor because a friend recommended it. the experience was the trip safe worth and eating was affordable. you can't go wrong with the pizza, salad or pasta. I give 5 stars and 5 thumbs to pizza sauce?

Good pie needs more sauce in the middle of the pie. Liked the crust. Bottom was on the crispy side. I’d go back.

Unbelievably rude staff and sub par food. There are rude children running this place. The staff here runs wild the second the owner isn't there apparently. They were so rude to me I walked out the other day. Right before they helped me they were joking around on the phone with people trying to make orders. Sorry, we don't have salad and things of that nature. There are way better pizza places downtown that know how to treat their customers.

Terrible Food. Smelled disgusting when it got to my house. Waste of my money. Can't believe they threw big burnt slices of pizza in a box and delivered that. Chicken mozzarella sticks were awful. Never ordering from here again.

Always a great meal, big portions for a great price ! Delivery time is spot on every time or even earlier, delivery guy is always polite “thank you for your business we really appreciate it “ !! When dining in , always friendly , fast service ! Give them a try never a disappointment ?