Fontana Pizzeria - Middle Village

Excellent Sicilian pie !! The owner Phil and all the people are very nice and helpful.Kid-friendliness: They go out of their way to always smile and say hello to the kids !

Has changed ownership 3 times. This is the best. I like the various food choices.Food: 5/5

I am a regular customer and generally always order a large pie with 1/2 sausage. Today, I ordered and something was way off with the sausage and also the cheese. The sausage completely tasted like it went bad. When I contacted the support on Slice (who contacted the pizzeria), all they offered me was $2 refund for the topping like I'm going to eat the rest of the pizza with juice from gone bad sausage and sour mozzarella. I don't know what happened today since I order from them all the time, but I definitely won't order again. They just lost a long time customer.

I was at a nearby shopping plaza and wanted a quick bite such as a slice of pizza but in a quiet atmosphere. Fontana provided just that. But instead of a regular cheese pizza, I tried the pasta pizza. I was very pleased with the combination. The restaurant also provided a comfortable Italian decor and many more options.Food: 5/5

I just tried this pizza and wow it’s has to be 1 of the best in NYC