Vennari's Pizza - Lewisburg

Use to be a great place with high quality and more natural ingredients. My last experience left a lot to be desired. My pizza was burned pretty badly. I am not sure how anyone could box it up and give it to a customer. I didn't ask for well done or extra crispy pizza ?

Mystery hours. They either spin a wheel or roll dice to determine if they're open.

I order here often and their food is typically excellent... However tonight was horrendous!!! So my family and I call in and place a order for 1 large cheesesteak with fried onion and sweet pepper. And a large cheesesteak stromboli with fried onion, mushrooms and pepperoni. We drove from mifflinburg to pick up. When we get there he tells us he forgot to put in pepperoni tells us he can make another but we'd have to wait. We say no bcus we just wanna go. We get home I open my cheesesteak and there's mayo, tons of it, all over the thing, I hate mayo. So I call tell the guy not only did you forget the pepperoni on the stromboli but you put mayo on my cheese steak and I didn't even ask for mayo. He says he'll remake both. So we drive all the way back, wait for them to get done. Get back home and I open my cheesesteak. The pepper were placed on the bottom, my roll was completely wet and falling apart bcus he put wet peppers straight on the roll and they cold. So I take a bite bcus at this point I'm just going to eat it as is.. and there's hot peppers put on it not sweet peppers as I had asked for and of course I can't eat hot peppers. Then we open the stromboli, he didn't chop the steak, theres whole pieces of steak and pepperoni just laid on dough, didn't even mix it together. ? Just Ridiculous really. Never will I eat here again unless it's the regular guy working, the regular guy can make a bomb cheesesteak!! this guy had no business making food if he didnt know what he was doing. I always say if you don't know what you're doing ASK FOR HELP!!

Grew up loving this pizza- no clue what happened here in the last 6 months but... Sigh. Tried to get delivery- brusque is polite. Long story short- didn't order anything.

Eat here about 3 to 4 times a week. Friendly staff and great food for good prices..