Italian Pie - Lawrenceville

I’m a regular, I come everyday for lunch and it never ceases to amaze me. As a New Yorker, I’m very picky about my pizza but Italian pie reminds me of home and the host Javier is very pleasant and friendly.Food: 5/5

Service was horrible. Ordered 2 pepperoni slices and after 45min and 3 reminders they still forgot my order. The cook had attitude in the back when questioned about the food. The cashier seemed not to care when I kept asking about my food. Seems to be a lot better when the owner is at the location vs not at the location.Food: 4/5

Very disappointed with the quality of the pizza. The guy who took the order was very pleasant, but $50 for less than mediocre pizza is ridiculous. The quality has definitely gone down since I’ve eaten here over a year ago.Food: 1/5

Food is 10/10 and the price is average. the staff is kind and welcoming and the pizza is so so good like litterly everything here is so good it dosnt matter what. the pictures on yelp are not accurate and I don't know why it's a 2.5 rating this is the best pizza I have had.

Just had dinner here for the first time. I thought the garlic rolls were really good. Would definitely order those again. We had a meat lover's pizza which I also thought was pretty good. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but it was good. Pizza prices were comparable to other pizza places in the area. The garlic rolls were quite a bit cheaper than another pizza place we frequent.We'll return maybe try a calzone or sandwich next time.