Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Feedback

First time in the pie shop. Had a small pie after lunch. Mmmmm good! Quick courteous service. Definitely going back for a big pie for Thanksgiving.

I love this place! Our holidays just wouldn't be complete without pies from Buttermilk Sky. I can't wait to pick up my order for Easter!

I’ve never had a bad experience! Great service, exceptional pie!

My husband just brought home a spiced pumpkin pie from Buttermilk Sky Pie and it was hands down the best pie I've ever tasted. I don't even want to share with t...

Pie is Great ! Myself being of my age we won't discuss that but I've been around a while I have eaten a lot of pie ! I had never heard of Buttermilk Sky Pie Sho...

Buttermilk sky has the best cake around! I had the pawn and pumpkin pussies around the celebrations, and for ostern my brother brought the earthly. delicious do...

The menu may be limited, but each dish is prepared perfectly. Anyone who enjoys Pecan Pie and chocolate must try the I-40. The coconut dessert was one of the be...

The peanut butter cream cake and chocolate chip cakes were excellent. We also had thumbprint cookies, which I really enjoyed. Unlike other bakeries which have a...

Indulging in the delicious cakes at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is definitely worth the splurge. Their selection includes large (9 inch) and small (4 inch) cakes in...