Key West Key Lime Pie Company

You could not tell the gluten free pie was gluten free, Amazing.

Thank you Marcus! Great little store front. All the staff was great!!! Place was spotless and easy to move around. Only standing standing room to eat the yummy Key Lime pie, chocolate dipped pc and the ice cream. Yes we had all 3 before lunch. So darn good.

I love their key lime pies! On Dec 31 I tried a traditional one and the one with more filling... Delicious! The staff is really friendly. The only problem I had was with a Sweet Pete's Candy Dark Chocolate Key Lime Pie that had expired in August and was in a bad condition... I couldn't see the date because the price tag was covering it...

Tried a regular slice of Key lime pie and a frozen chocolate covered slice. The regular slice was OK but the chocolate covered slice was amazing. There is no where to eat inside currently, so all orders are to go. They also take your temperature before allowing you inside.

Definitely top 5 Key Lime pie slices I had down there. I wish I tried the extra tart! Their homemade whip cream is to die for! The texture of the key lime pie was excellent