Bella Sicilia - Johnstown

Rolled in on our way home from a late night of soccer at two minutes to closing tired and hungry. The owner came out to greet us and told us to sit down relax and enjoy a meal. We did. Fantastic sauce maybe the best I’ve had out. For all you young people out there wondering how you’re gonna make it in this world. I don’t care what line of work you are in. Learn good customer service. This is how you treat people, and it is rare. Check out Bella Cicilia...you won’t be disappointed.

Unfortunately, I was less impressed during my second visit. The antipasto salad consisted of sliced luncheon meats, and we had to request Parmesan cheese, which they provided in a small cup. It was a Sunday afternoon, and when one of us ordered meat sauce for their pasta, we were informed that it was not available, but meatballs could be ordered instead. We also had to ask for drink refills. Overall, the limited menu, unavailable items, and reduced service made me concerned that the restaurant might be struggling. I truly hope that's not the case, as the food I've had has been delicious, and our waitress during the first visit was very nice. It's still worth a trip to give it a try.

The food was excellent, and our server, Shelly, provided outstanding service. The wild mushroom dip paired with the fresh, house-made pita bread was so delicious that we couldn't get enough of it! We will certainly return!

We've been visiting Bella Sicilia for a year, and it just keeps improving! The food is outstanding, the menu offers a great variety, and the staff is friendly. We also appreciate the BYOB policy. It's a kid-friendly spot, and I believe they feature live music on the second Saturday of each month, which adds a wonderful touch. If you enjoy authentic Italian cuisine, you shouldn't miss Bella Sicilia!