Brooklyn Square Pizza Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Awesome pizza if you like Sicilian pies. Only had the square . Wife prefers a thinner slice.

Alright, folks, we're in Jackson, New Jersey, and you know what time it is. One Bite, everybody knows the rules. Today, we're checking out Brooklyn Square Pizza. Now, don't get it twisted—this isn't Brooklyn, New York, but let me tell you, these guys are bringing the heat. First off, you walk in, and you know these guys mean business. The place has that classic pizzeria vibe. No frills, just good pizza. They even have a slice joint feel, which is always a good sign. The smell alone had me fired up before I even took a bite. Now, let's talk about the main event—the pizza. This pie has got some serious weight to it. It's like they took all the best parts of a Brooklyn pie and pumped it up on Jersey steroids. The crust? Absolute perfection. Crispy on the outside, but soft enough on the inside to hold up all that cheesy goodness without turning into a soggy mess. And the cheese-to-sauce ratio? Spot on. You can tell these guys aren't skimping on the ingredients. The first bite? Oh man. You get hit with that flavor explosion. The sauce has that nice tang, the cheese is ooey-gooey, and the crust has that perfect char. This is the kind of slice that makes you wanna go back for another, and maybe even another after that. Listen, I've eaten a lot of pizza, and this one definitely stands out. Brookly Square Pizza is bringing some serious game. If you're anywhere near Jackson, NJ, you gotta stop by. This might just be one of the best pies you’ll find outside of New York City. Final score? I’m going with an 8.9. Brooklyn Square Pizza, you earned it. One bite, everybody knows the rules.

The square pie is on point. Sauce cheese and doe is great. Got a chicken vodka penne dinner and chicken saltimbocca over penne, top notch. Fresh seasoned chicken, sauce was full of flavor and portions were great. By the pictures u can see i dug in way before i got the pic lol. Its 15mins away but worth the drive. Plus last the bread for dipping in the sauce, not many places have good bread and always seem to fall short but not them. I was very satisfied

Placed order and was not given our salads as shown on the menu! My husband asked when picking up the food and they told him salad is for dine in only! Then why would it state salad w baked entrees included? I had baked ziti and he had baked rigatoni w mozzarella on top which was also not done! We have lived in Howell almost 3 years now and have been here many times BUT not anymore! I’m surprised at the customer service and the lack of communication between the website and workers who both said no to our salads at the time of pick up!

The Brooklyn pie is excellent. It's kinda the size of a Sicilian pizza. We enjoy it