Tally-ho Supper Club - Hayward

Absolutely incredible dining experience. From beginning to end, it's an absolute treat. Tom and his crew care deeply about both the quality and presentation of every drink and dish that hits the table and it shows.

Unforgettable Supper Club Extravaganza! 5 Stars is NOT enough!!!Wow, where do I even begin? My recent experience at Tally Ho Supper Club was nothing short of extraordinary, earning it a well-deserved 5 stars!The culinary journey was an absolute masterpiece. Each course was a symphony of flavors, a dance of textures, and a work of art on the plate. It was evident that the chefs poured their hearts into creating dishes that not only delighted the taste buds but also sparked conversations around the table.What truly set this supper club apart was the warm and engaging staff....especially our server, Richie. His knowledge of the menu, paired with his genuine passion for ensuring every guest felt welcome and pampered, created an atmosphere that was both relaxed and refined. He was our evening's entertainment was the cherry on top of an already splendid night.In summary, this supper club experience was an absolute triumph. It's rare to find an event that combines exquisite cuisine, impeccable service, enchanting entertainment, and a genuine sense of community. I left with a heart full of joy, a belly full of delectable dishes, and memories that will undoubtedly stay with me for a lifetime. If you're seeking a truly extraordinary dining experience that transcends the ordinary, look no further – this supper club is an absolute must!Bravo to the entire team for orchestrating an evening that was nothing short of magical. I eagerly await the opportunity to relive this enchanting journey on my next visit!

Great supper club experience. I don’t get some of the reviews. Our group of 9 ordered frog legs, prime rib, seafood trio, pork tenderloin, duck, walleye, appetizers including fried cheese curds. All the food was served hot and was good just what you would expect from a supper club. Relish tray was good too. Device was good waitresses were extremely busy and still provided good service. Food was not overpriced we had a designated driver so had a few drinks and total came to about 85.00 per person including generous tip. Going out to eat now at anything other than fast food or tavern/bar food is expensive and this is not Applebees or Texas Road House, it is much better. By the way, the homemade dinner rolls are great.

Do not waste your time. Saying this place is overpriced, is keeping this clean and appropriate. If you ask questions they will become defensive. I have never left a review before, but one should be warned, this is not a supper club experience. You are not only wasting your evening, the linger of the owner's rightness still leaves a bad taste. I waited a month to calm myself before writing this.

We knew the prices were high and we wanted the supper club experience. It’s a cute place. I called ahead to ask if they had a kids menu and he said they did. We ordered 3 kids spaghetti and meatballs for a 3, 4 and 8 year old. We ordered apps and a couple of drinks per person. The kid’s spaghetti was not on the menu but when we got the bill.. it was 25 dollars each. If you want to discourage families w kids from coming, at least publish the prices for the “kids” menu. It was just so off putting. We won’t be back.