Coffaros' Pizza - Feedback

Nice small shop. We went in on the Sunday of Labor Day Weekend. I didn’t catch the guys name, but he was very personable. We got the deluxe and steak pizzas. Pr...

Traveling from Wisconsin for a wedding in Newfoundland pa.we stayed in Grove City pa.found coffaro's on line.well worth ordering.was ready in about 10 minutes....

Absolutely delicious! I was in the area for a night and Coffaros ' Pizza was highly recommended.This is one of THE best pizzas I 've had! The crust is chewy, cr...

They have the best pizza in Grove City!!! Wonderful, hard working staff! This is me and my boyfriend’s favorite pizza place! It is heavenly goodnesssss, try the...

Subs were good. Pizza was good too but I think it needs more sauce, but that's me. Parking: Parking on street or on side street lot.

I ordered 2 salads for delivery, paid $20 including the tip, then discovered that there is no cutlery and no dressing for the salad. When I complained to the gi...

First they have best Wimgs in town! Big pizza and subs! But more important is the type of people who are the owners! Together with the pizza shop they have seve...

Coffaro's: great pizza, good price. Can't you say how often our office has run past to get a piece or order a special pizza from Coffaro's. Not only convenience...

I usually never command because most of the chain pizzas in Grove City are terrible. Coffaro's was the only pizza shop in town and I hadn't tried yet, but I'm s...

I like Caffaro's pizza, so I was hungry for wings today. I've never had it from here and I wanted to try. We ordered the hot wings waited 50 minutes, which is n...

I have ordered lunch on 2 different dates and the delivery has been late each time. I do not recommend. When I tried to contact them, I was put on hold and not...

This has been our go to pizza place for years; incredible food and very kind people. Highly recommend over any other establishment including the Dominos. If you...

Honestly the best pizza I’ve had in a LONG time. The cheesy bread sticks are absolutely amazing and the chicken bacon ranch pizza is the best I’ve had from anyw...

When you ask for extra sauce and cheese you get lite cheese and sauce slopped on top of the cheese

Awesome and friendly as you can get. The calzones are huge, great sauce and fresh as it gets. The dough is fresh and easy to tell its a hometown diamond in the...