Gib's New York Bagels - Fort Collins

I love the multigrain bagel option as well as the sweet bagel bites and the wide variety of coffee options. I just wish they could get their online ordering down. It doesn't seem like they read the ticket at all; every time I pickup my order they forget my coffee or don't make my bagel the way I ordered.

My and my girlfriend are visiting from out of town, and we’ve eaten here every day for 4 days straight. Great little bagel spot, friendly service, quick and very fairly priced. I love the pickle spears with the Sandwhiches! The Rueben with sauerkraut is my favorite so far but today I had the NYC and it’s fantastic. Lots of bagel options to choose from as well!

Decent bagels, but very disappointing service. They constantly forget items and often get my order wrong. This has happened to me multiple times where one or more bagels have been missing. If ordering online, be certain to check your order because they certainly won’t.

I was hoping for a better experience and a better bagel.The Hot Pastrami I ordered was fine. It wasn't the most fabulous pastrami, but it was acceptable. The bagel didn't seem particularly fresh, but wasn't bad.When I asked about the drink I had ordered, the person bringing the bagel to the counter argued with me about it. I don't need medium food with free added bad attitude.I had hopes for a new sandwich option. I'll pass on this one.

Noms. My kid prefers Gibs to Lamar's donuts. That says a lot. Highly recommend.