Stagecoach Inn - Fort Atkinson

I was SO excited to see Lobster Bites on the menu. It was an all-time favorite at a supper club that closed years ago. For me, the breading was just far too sweet. I would have been very happy with a more traditional one, if that modification was available, I'd order this again, but not as it is now. It was an unexpected disappointment. Everything else was top notch, and Madison, our sever, couldn't have been better. We'll be back!

Stopped in on a Tuesday night at 5pm thinking we could just sit at the bar and have a few drinks, the place was packed! The owner was kind enough to put us at a table and we ended up having one of the best meals we have had in a while! Everything was great and priced well! Definitely recommend. The owner tells great jokes too!

The staff is amazing. This place is busy every time I have been there. It's the best in the area so make a reservation. There will always be a wait. It's worth it though.

Was more expensive than it should be for a low quality steak equivalent to a grocery store. Service was terrible, we reserved a table four days in advance and yet still had to wait almost an hour for our table. I mean people just walking in sat before us. Just avoid this place if you want good service and better food.

I truly wished we had tried this restaurant before now! Our steaks were phenomenal and cooked exactly to our liking. The meat was tender and full of flavor! With drinks at the bar before the meal, 2 steak dinners with an appetizer and take home dessert, our bill was only 119. Truly a gem! We will be back!