Pudgie's - Elmira

The staff was very helpful and friendly, pizza tasted amazing and was cheaper than expected, especially with how many decent... My kids and I enjoyed the pizza at Pudgies.

Pizza tasted excellent. They forgot to give us plates napkins. When I ordered asked for them they said yes to the plates

Wings to die for so yummy and pizza was on point . Always served fresh . Nice friendly staff. Been here twice for pickup .

Once I got home and opened it, I had a slice, and instantly, it transported me back to Grandma’s house in 1998! It had half meat sauce and half pepperoni—just perfect! I called them and said, “It tastes just as amazing as it looks!” Thank you, Kevin, for putting such care into your work. I’m not one to complain or fuss, but I definitely believe in giving credit where it’s due! I had to snap a photo of this beauty. Hahaha!

I'm absolutely thrilled to share this review! When I was younger, my mother worked at the original Pudgies store in Mansfield, so we enjoyed a lot of pizza back then. Fast forward over twenty years, and I've been living far from a Pudgies. Whenever we visit family in Pennsylvania, we make it a priority to order from here. On this recent trip, we stopped by the Elmira location, and the pizza was hot, fresh, and downright delicious. It was also special because it was my daughter's first time trying Pudgies, giving her a taste of the experience I cherished growing up. I couldn't be happier with our visit! A huge thanks to the Elmira team for their incredible pizza and professionalism. Now, if only you could open a store in Utah so we wouldn't have to travel so far!