Strathmore Bagels - East Setauket

Still the best bagels in town! I’ve been a customer for a while Today I brought bagels to a relative in a nursing home. We reminisced on the not so distant past of having a great New York City bagel like these. crisp on the outside soft on the inside and delicious just like these D-Lish.

The bagels are really good and soft. The staff are friendly and helpful. I ordered the garlic bagel with bacon, egg and cheese. Im new to New York so it was the first time I tried garlic bagel. They have variety of bagels to choose from. Would love to try other bagels. The coffee was average. Overall a great place for dine in or take out.

Best Everything on Roll egg Sandwich I had all summer....and they are REALLY nice there...Thanks Dan...

Good breakfast sandwiches. Wish they were open later.

Great bagels, long lines. This neighborhood outpost of Strathmore uses local teenagers behind the counter which can be a hit or miss proposition. The painfully slow system and bad layout ensure that anyone in a hurry for a bagel and coffee or just a dozen bagels will be frustrated. Still the best bagels around and usually served with a smile.