Johnny Macaroni's West Street

Excellent value, outstanding food and service made reservations through open table, did not have to wait past reservation time the food was fantastic, very large amount of food served I had the gnocci, very good, too much for me to eat, took home three quarters of the meal another guest at our table had the veal parm, he loved it, also large amount of food he also took home leftovers had the tiramisu for desert again excellent would recommend the restaurant to anyone who like Italian food other food items looked good as well

First visit to Johnny Macaroni's and I loved it! The food was delicious, the drinks were awesome and the price was super affordable. I will be back soon!

The food was amazing! There was a problem with one meal and it was quickly taken care of. The plates are huge! Even the small portion is big! We were able to bring a cake in to celebrate a birthday. This was my first time there...but we will be back!

I had heard raves about this place, so was excited to finally try it. The service was slow and it took 45 minutes to get our meal. Admittedly it was busy on a Saturday night, however, we arrived earlier than most other guests, and when after 45 minutes, we told our waitress we were on a time constraint, she said well Saturdays are very busy, that's it. Didn't offer to check on our meals. As for the food, we had a meatball appetizer which was good. However, we weren't finished with it yet when the waitress walked by and took it away (she did box though thankfully). The salmon piccatta was underwhelming. The mushrooms lacked a good sauteed and looked like they had come from a can. The piccata sauce lacked zing. Scrod was okay. The tomato sauce over linguini wasn't anything special.

Johnny Macaroni's is a very cozy restaurant with friendly staff, great drinks and delicious food. We absolutely love their Chicken Broccoli Ziti Alfredo. The Chicken Parmesan is also excellent and their portions are quite generous. One of our favorite restaurants. We'll be back!