Insider's Sandwiches - Cottage Grove

My wife and I had the pleasure of trying Papa Jimmy's pizzeria tonight. We both really enjoyed the thin crust pepperoni pizza. If you have pizza with a good crispy crust like us, then you will enjoy throughout. Cheese great, pepperoni excellent, and if you add in some delicious sauce, it is amazing. The breadsticks were really soft and padded. These were my wife's favorites and they enjoyed the dusting of Parmesan cheese above. I ordered the mozzerella sticks for me (no, I didn't split Lol). These are my favorite mozzerella sticks. There are some places that carry similar tasting versions of these, and I enjoy them every time. Yum! And we can't forget to mention the ice cream. The chocolate shop has the best ice cream ever and cried out Papa Jimmy to serve it. will eat again

Excellent service and good, they rock! Really sweet Eatery! Two of us ate two big subs for $20.

Amazing customer service when I came in and so great pizza! I had the chicken alfredo and the Taco specialties. I've blown away how fresh it is. Quality ingredients, presentation, and I feel great after eating and not weighed like with other pizzas. I will definitely order again. Thank you.

That's actually the best pizza place. This place deserves a 5-star rating. Ps, if you want to have a good laugh, read the one star reviews in this place.

Ingredients always taste so fresh. Love their marinara. And they're always so nice and patient when ordering.