Milk - City of New York

The birthday cake and pumpkin pie were fine. I was expecting better but they were really small for the price and the flavors didnt wow me. I liked the texture of the pie though it was very gooey. I think I would just stick with their ice cream.

As some others here have noticed, the staff seems to be really inattentive. At least I was greeted when entering the place, but the employee behind the counter seemed to rather work on their laptop than take my order. Waited for a few minutes then left. Didn 't even get a goodbye when leaving.Apparently being hyped eliminates the need for customer service. ?

I came here from New Jersey on June 12th to the nicest (and cutest) guy behind the counter! He was so knowledgeable about all the product offerings and funny as well ! He recommended the BDay cake shake to me and it tasted soooo good and he made it so fast ! The experience was amazing from start to finish and I will definitely be visiting here again soon

If there was a minus I would give it. Came all way from UK for my birthday to have a slice of birthday cake was so excited after seeing it on Netflix to find the rudest, most uninterested staff I have ever met. The girl on the counter ignored us for 10 minutes while she stood texting on her phone, she hardly spoke to us, no please, thank you or anything. The guy who made our order made no eye contact didn’t speak and was equally as rude! Failed to give us the order we made and didn’t even indicate that our order was ready.Wouldn’t mind but the actual items were sub-standard and poor probably because they say you can taste good when it’s made with love! Thanks for shattering my impression and really putting a downer on my birthday!

Awful customer service. Trying to get the server to answer questions was like getting blood out of the stone. Such a shame as I'd been wanting to get the desserts here since watching the netflix episode on cristina tosi. The cereal milk soft serve was ok, and very expensive. The milk bar pie was nice, was again, very expensive. Would not recommend mainly because of the customer service. Had it been a pleasant experience, I think my review would have had a few more stars as the actual food was ok, if overpriced.