Goodfellas Pizzeria - City of Amsterdam

Ordered from them several times. Always the same. Food is cold when I get it. I have called for pick up and I get out on hold for over 20 min then I show up there still on hold and they blame it on the phones. Still tell me 35 min for 2 sandwiches. I give up on this place.

Fantastic pizza! Cooked perfectly. My kids love the pizza too! Staff are friendly and prices are reasonable. We will definitely order from here again.

From the menu that's advertised I ordered a 6 cut cheese..$8.50. 2 12pc wings at 10.50 a piece..$21.00. I see the receipt and it's a little under $50 for the whole order. Called the store asking for prices and apparently the chicken jumped up to $16. Even with that the amount is less than what I was charged smh. The pizza sucked and my mild wings tasted like to much hot pepper flakes drowned in a sweet sauce it was gross. DO NOT ORDER!!! call fresh basil or Joe's!!!

Terrible food! The boneless wings were just drowned in some sauce that was so sweet it was disgusting. Also I place an order at 5:20 pm and the food got here at 7:13 pm. The food was room temperature and kinda tasted stale. Never again! $30 down the drain for a terrible meal.

I initially gave this restaurant a one-star rating, but after giving it another try, I can confidently say it deserves a better score. It's definitely a great spot for delicious pizza and fantastic mozzarella sticks!