Oddfellows Ice Cream Co.

Pretty good ice cream spot in the beautiful chestnut hill area. The different varieties is really nice to have on the hard ice cream with different unique flavors. The soft serve options only have 2 flavors unfortunately, would be great if they could add a couple more different flavors. It would definitely make for some interesting and tasteful options to have a twist ice cream cone with different flavors of soft serve. Overall really nice place service was prompt andfriendly.

Awesome, Satisfying. They are very creative in making newer flavours and varieties of Iced products of Milk, Cream, Fruits, Wines and Spirits. You feel like having me every time you eat out in and around this area in Newton. Good place for family party as well.

VERY disappointed. Didn’t open until 2pm and when they did, they still hadn’t set up the freezers so we had to wait 15 minutes while one of the employees set everything up. Now mind you, there were three employees there and only one person was working the counter and preparing it. These things should be done BEFORE you open so that your business is ready to serve their customers, ESPECIALLY if you don’t open until 2pm. On top of that, the bathroom was DISGUSTING. We were the first customers of the day so we know that there was no one there before us and there was pee ALL over the toilet seat. Do we not clean up before closing the night before? And do we not check the cleanliness of the shop before we open? Evidently not since they weren’t even ready to take orders when they opened. Will not be returning until changes are made in regards to work ethic.

Not a patch on JP Licks! Tried 4 flavors at the Chestnut Hill, MA store. None of them lived up to their enticing, creative labels! The sea salt pistachio looked green alright but had no pistachio bits neither did it smell nor taste like pistachio ice-cream. The Coffee crunch had nothing crunchy; instead, I could get a taste of bits of cake in it. There was miso something. Didn't taste either like miso or anything else. Overall, not a good experience. Do not plan to return.

Lovely place! And if you want something soury-sweet go for the exotic fruit taste! And I love their near by lake!