Godfather's Pizza - Chatham

I ordered a classic combo pizza and it came out terrible! No mushrooms and onions. Little black olives, sausage and pepperoni were on it. The cook says Very little mushroom on it.For a $25 pizza, I 'd shop elsewhere!!! Also this place is designed for gambling which make me sad. Looks like Chatham Godfather is into gambling business, not pizza. I will NOT be coming back there anymore! BTW, the ones in Springfield on Wabash is MUCH better! Go there if you can. On the ironic part, I asked to Dine In and ended up with a Carry Out .

We ordered two pizzas and monkey bread , 69.00 and it was so not worth it . Very little toppings and the Carmel monkey bread had not taste of Carmel . Never again and will not recommend to anyone so very disappointing!

We ordered our pizza and wanted to eat in. Was self-serve for your drinks, plates, silverware. I attempted to get 2 plates from stack of plates. I picked up multiple plates and all were dirty. I went to counter and ask the young man if he had other plates that were clean. He shrugged his shoulders and informed me that was all they had. I said well they are dirty. He again shrugged. When my husband went to get silverware, same thing, dirty. Ended up taking to bathroom and washing them. Bad as bathroom was filthy too.Pizza was excellent but had trouble enjoying thinking about the potential dirty kitchen. Won't come back.

The pizza is pretty good at this place and the employees seemed friendly. There were two minor issues. The first is that the pizza here is a bit pricy compared to other places unless you buy one of the deals. The other issue was that they seemed to be really busy but only had two employees working so it took an hour to get the pizzas. It's probably not always like this but on this Friday evening, it was.

I love this location because the employees have been there as long as I have been going. They are always so kind! Not to mention the cheese sticks are my FAVORITE in town. I would recommend this place for any pizza needs and PLEASE remember to tip them! Not as many people sit inside and most places have had to outsource their delivery.