Centerville Pie Co.

Maybe it?s because we ordered the frozen pies by mail but both chicken and shepherds were a big disappointment. And they were expensive. Chicken with no vegetables was unhealthy and boring. Shepherds only had mashed potatoes and corn and it lackedflavor. I can make much better at home.

A bright spot on our Cape vacation! Enjoyed several dinner as well as desert pies. Chicken, shepherds, apple, barbecue. Highly recommend! Great people and great pie!

I bought 3 boxes of the mini’s. Big mistake!! I’m an old born and bred southern/country Gal and these were not good!! Dry, tasteless, and chicken was tough!! I tried 3 of the mini’s trying to give them the benefit of the doubt but it was all i could do to stomach them. Threw the rest in trash. The regular pie maybe better but I will never know. I will go back to the lady that makes them in my area.

Their pie shop is Centerville is fantastic and offers tasty pies but my review is for the their frozen Shepard's pie I got from stop and shop. These other reviews seem aggressive regarding the frozen pies, I thought it was very tasty, my only suggestion is that it could use another filling with the beef and corn, maybe some carrots or peas? Maybe add both! I ended up cooking some peas on the side and just added it to my pie. Crust was very good. A bit pricey but it's no more expensive than Marie Callenders pies at the store and IMO much tastier. Cheers.

The chicken pot pie that we bought frozen at Market Basket was inedible.Baked as directed, the bottom crust was raw, and the top crust was half cooked. Several giant chunks of chicken were tough and dry and wouldn’t even cut with a knife. Four slices of carrot throughout the pie. No flavor at all.