Gyro Jimmy's - CARLE PLACE

First time trying this place and I can see why it has so many 5* reviews. I got their beef lamb gyro with a side of pita bread. Everything was fresh and flavorful. I also love the fact that they put fries inside the gyro! Staff was also nice, I will be returning. 5*

I ordered dinner here tonight because of all the five star reviews, but I can’t see what all the hype is about. I ordered the chicken Gyro Skepasti and it was decent, but not really good.I ordered the garlic cream sauce on the side instead of their secret sauce, and maybe that’s where I went wrong? The chicken Gyro itself was decent but not very flavorful like others I have had in the area.The restaurant itself looks very nice, but the food wasn’t very impressive. I went to The Great Gyro yesterday and was more impressed with their chicken Gyro than this place.Parking: There is a parking lot that is fairly big, but there are also a lot of stores and finding parking may be difficult at peak hours.

There was no wait. We were from our of town so we were not sure how this would taste so I asked to taste the meat and DELICIOUS is all I can say. I ate mine before the long ride home but my daughter wanted to try it. She loved it and I had to go back in to get her one. We had the traditional gyro. You will not be disappointed. If we are ever in long island again, we will be coming back! ?Vegetarian options: There is hummus, spinach pie, falafel, lentil soup, salad, meatless gyro (vegan friendly), vegetarian mousaka, pasticcio, etc... there is enough to please.Parking: Shares a lot with other businesses. After having wonderful food you can go ace throwing next door.Kid-friendliness: Wide open space. Not formal seating just like other pizza places.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs

Great option if you are looking for a quick Greek food fix. Nice place, clean, well-managed. Great gyros!

Food is always good and fresh. They have 6 different lunch specials which is nice. I visit here regularly.