Di Fara Pizzeria - Feedback

If this truly is the best pizza in NYC, then I'm confused as to why we have a NYC at all.

I came here a quarter after noon and they still weren't ready.

Made a pilgrimage to Brooklyn just for this. Easily the best slice of pizza I 've ever eaten fresh out of the oven, with oil and basil. There 's a reason Anthon...

I grew up eating this pizza ever since I was 8. This place contains many memories for me and I always regarded the pizza as the best. definitely recommend a try...

At first, I was disappointed after I got the square. It was a 7.2 for me. I probably just had a bad slice; it may have been out for too long. The person who I w...

What a Christmas miracle. My gf was from out of town and we came from Dyker Heights and they were closed. Dino saw us and opened up the back door and told us to...

The pizza I had was a round pie with pepperoni, and it goes down as my new favorite NYC pizza. The slice I had had a gracious amount of parmesan and the perfect...

You are not there for the atmosphere it’s probably 80 yrs old. However the pizza is one of the best. The Sicilian corner of course!!!

I am not writing this review to tell you what to do with your hard-earned money. I am going to share my thoughts and you make your own decision if you would lik...

Well since the old man is gone everything went downhill at this joint. Used to be the best pizza in Brooklyn not anymore! $5 for a regular slice is 100% NOT WOR...

Comes with a tough reputation to back-up. Not sure anything can live up to all that hype but the pizza was excellent. I preferred the regular slice over the squ...

The crusty on the regular pie was really doughy and soft.... felt like chewing bubble gum.

The square pizza was slightly burnt and a bit soggy, but it was still better than 80% of the pizza in NYC. The round pizza, however, is definitely superior.

I rated it based on the delivery experience. The food arrived cold. However, their pizza could be the best I've ever tasted!

I was on vacation in Brooklyn and heard that Di Fara is one of the best pizza places in New York. I ordered the Classic Pie, and it did not disappoint. The pizz...

Hands down the best pizza place in New York. If you are a pizza lover then Di Fara Pizza place is for you to try and enjoy amazing delicious authentic Italian p...

Fantastic pizza, you gotta get the square slice! nobody does it better, the crust is so crispy and delicious even with all the sauce and cheese. order online ah...

I decided to take my wife on my second visit during lunch, really building it up for her. We ordered both slices and square pizzas, as several reviews mentioned...

This restaurant has received a lot of buzz, and it's absolutely deserved. It fully lives up to its reputation. Without a doubt, it's the best pizza in all of Ne...

Honestly, I’m surprised this place doesn’t have a perfect 5-star rating everywhere. The service was outstanding, and everyone was incredibly friendly. While the...