Gem City Saloon And Eatery - Feedback

I got a pizza to go. We are new in town. There wasn’t enough flavor in the sauce and our pepperoni and cheese was burnt around the corners. I was pretty bummed...

If you find yourself in Baraboo, WI, and are on the hunt for a place that combines great food, a welcoming atmosphere, and a bit of fun, Gem City Saloon Eatery...

For a blind pick, Gem City was a winner ... My wife and I both agree it's the best pizza we've ever had ... Our server was awesome ... Hope it doesn't change be...

Great place! Pizza is huge. Apps were awesome. We'll be back

Everything was perfect , food , service and kind staff member . Highly recommended

Absolutely amazing pizza is great to heat it the next day or even freeze and it is a month later to eat it is very good as it is for the service, I think that i...

Took a chance with this place without looking at any of the reviews. Luckily the table next to us had ordered a couple of the establishments famous pizzas, so I...

It will be rude to his service here, survive it and enjoy yourself. It's part of the vibe. You don't do a table service. Expect to order at the bar. Everything...

Best Pizza in Baraboo!. If you ever have a chance to stop in Gem City Saloon in Baraboo Wisconsin, you need to try the pizza. One of the best I ever had! This p...

Husband and I travel a lot and enjoy trying new places. Didn’t feel the love when we first came in but we’re super friendly people, so could just be us? We orde...

Out with family celebrating a couple birthdays and GEM fit the bill. Great attentive service! Pizzas, sandwich and wings were more than enough. Love the atmosph...

A local in Baraboo recommended we try the Gem City Saloon for their pizza, so we went, and it was amazing! Pictured here is the pan pizza with cheese, mushroom,...

Amazing pizza, excellent service. Great place to stop enjoy the game! They are killing it! Bar atmosphere but yep we are from Wisconsin that is where you find t...

If you like Detroit style deep dish pizza this is your place!!! A large can feed a family of 6 easily and they also have some good original down and dirty apps!...

Came here for dinner because we heard the pizza was delicious. Very true. Ordered one thin crust and one small pan and both were amazing. We had 4 ladies in our...

Their pizza is great! Consistent everytime we go!! If u like thick crust that is crisp this is the place! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1...

Amazing food old time saloon/pub feel! The price is right, portion sizes sre huge. Must try the awesome pizza!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per pers...

Great place, food and service! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

If you like Pizza eat here. Hands down the best pizza ever. And yes it is a dive type bar. But the pizza is amazing. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5