Insomnia Cookies - Amherst

The few paints I was here the service was quick friendly and the cookies were amazing. the confetti deluxe is my favorite!

Must sound very weird, but it was the first time in my 21 years on Earth to enter a cookie store past 10pm ish, and it left such a good impression. I'm not a big fan of sweet eats, but this place downright convinced my heart and mind. I ordered a deluxe salted caramel for $4.28. Price was definitely not cheap, so minus 1 star . Customer service was unexpectedly wonderful, given that nighttime staff elsewhere would typically feel reluctant to serve. They carefully asked if I wanted a paper plate or a double open bag for takeout.Recalling all my cookie tasting memories, I think this is the best cookie I have ever had. They handed the cookie to me lukewarm. First bite was exactly like described in the title, very ooey gooey. You could feel that batter hot out of the oven melting in your mouth. The texture was soft, wet, a little crispy, and sticky; nothing could compare to it!! When I first held it, it broke into medium sized parts that fit my chewing capacity. Yummy, but one is enough for the night because it's cloyingly sweet at some point. Please handle it with care, or it will break into piecesOverall, very positive experience in my first attempt at ordering and tasting a cookie. Also feeling thankful because there was a suddenly long, long queue after my order ?‍?P/s: Highly recommend for late night sugar cravers!! Opening until 1AM ?

Must sound very weird, but it was the first time in my 21 years on Earth to enter a cookie store past 10pm ish, and it left such a good impression. I'm not a big fan of sweet eats, but this place downright convinced my heart and mind. I ordered a deluxe salted caramel for $4.28. Price was definitely not cheap, so minus 1 star. Customer service was unexpectedly wonderful, given that nighttime staff elsewhere would typically feel reluctant to serve. They carefully asked if I wanted a paper plate or a double open bag for takeout. Recalling all my cookie tasting memories, I think this is the best cookie I have ever had. They handed the cookie to me lukewarm. First bite was exactly like described in the title, very ooey gooey. You could feel that batter hot out of the oven melting in your mouth. The texture was soft, wet, a little crispy, and sticky; nothing could compare to it!! When I first held it, it broke into medium sized parts that fit my chewing capacity. Yummy, but one is enough for the night because it's cloyingly sweet at some point. Please handle it with care, or it will break into pieces Overall, very positive experience in my first attempt at ordering and tasting a cookie. Also feeling thankful because there was a suddenly long, long queue after my order!! P/s: Highly recommend for late night sugar cravers!! Opening until 1AM. Will definitely come back with reviews of their ice cream and chocolate milk.

Must sound very weird, but it was the first time in my 21 years on Earth to enter a cookie store past 10pm ish, and it left such a good impression. I'm not a big fan of sweet eats, but this place downright convinced my heart and mind. I ordered a deluxe salted caramel for $4.28. Price was definitely not cheap, so minus 1 star . Customer service was unexpectedly wonderful, given that nighttime staff elsewhere would typically feel reluctant to serve. They carefully asked if I wanted a paper plate or a double open bag for takeout. Recalling all my cookie tasting memories, I think this is the best cookie I have ever had. They handed the cookie to me lukewarm. First bite was exactly like described in the title, very ooey gooey. You could feel that batter hot out of the oven melting in your mouth. The texture was soft, wet, a little crispy, and sticky; nothing could compare to it!! When I first held it, it broke into medium sized parts that fit my chewing capacity. Yummy, but one is enough for the night because it's cloyingly sweet at some point. Please handle it with care, or it will break into pieces Overall, very positive experience in my first attempt at ordering and tasting a cookie. Also feeling thankful because there was a suddenly long, long queue after my order! P/s: Highly recommend for late night sugar cravers!! Opening until 1AM.

Wow do these cookies taste good! I won't subtract a stat for lack of gluten-free ones, but oh I wish they had them.