Stuart's Seafood Market - Amagansett

I am happy with the consistently fine quality and freshness of the fish I buy here. The prepared foods are also great.

Fantastic food great for picking up delicious catered app trays highly recommend!

Fresh seafood! Crystal is a guru of the fish! So friendly and helpful! She even helped me with a recipe to make my anniversary dinner so special mussels in wine sauce and a beautiful tuna steak! Thank you!! I look forward to coming back!

Fantastic selection! Clam pies (a hyper-local). Possibly the best lobster bisque I've ever had!

It’s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we’ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under 24 hours after squeezing lemon all over it and stuffing it with herbs to marinate. When you go in to the shop and even if you’re only looking for seafood, make a point to look at the produce…it’s on the cusp of being rotten. What a shame.