The Athenian Cafe Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

If you want authentic Greek food this is as close as you will get. As a younger woman I remember when this place first opened in the Juniata section of town. So with high expectations I traveled to the hold wash house on Union. I will return despite a few small issues. The hummus was very good but the ratio of hummus and pita forced us to order more pita so we could finish the dish. The first salad was topped with chicken when steak was ordered and lacked the correct dressing. The dolmades and the original gyro (lamb/beef) were delicious. They were out of baba ghanoush. The server had great enthusiasm and was super friendly but very loud when speaking, leaving her voice to carry in the small dining area, next time take out!

Got take out, food was decent. Steak kabobs, I wasn't impressed with. Greek chicken salad was legit tho.

Casey was the absolute best. The atmosphere is fresh and clean. Would definitely recommend eating here.

Delicious food waitresses were very helpful and knowledgeable

Amazing Greek food! This is a hidden gem! Everything is very fresh and made with order! They have the best Greek salads and gyros! The hummus appetizer is amazing! 10/10!